SoloStories: “The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies”

SoloStories is our feature in which we explore books, films and TV shows that show single women navigating their lives – but romance is not the main component. 

“The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies” by Alison Goodman, is a Regency novel with a unique perspective. Instead of focusing on romance in the ton, it’s about the realities of the time. Two 42-year-old single women in 1800s England rescue women in dire situations, relying on their wits and determination. Lady Augusta Coleman, also known as “Gus,” is outspoken, but her heart still yearns for a love she lost 20 years ago. Julia, recently widowed, is quieter and hiding a secret.

The book manages a light touch despite their harrowing adventures that take them into the worst parts of humanity. It can get tense, so you may need some biscuits to soothe you and a handkerchief to wipe your brows. This is a rare Regency that is inclusive, with main characters who are older in age and BIPOC and LBGTQIA characters in supporting roles.

The novel excels with some great dialogue, when Gus brings up a frequently used term while plotting their venture:

“I doubt anyone would ever believe two old maids could even take on such a venture.”

“Old maids. I really do hate that expression,” Julia said.

“Then let us be something else.”

“Useful,” Julia said. “I would like to have some purpose …”

“Then it is settled. We shall be useful. But just as importantly we shall be defiant, occasionally ill-mannered, and completely indomitable.”

The novel proves that despite the society’s degradation of the women’s status, they provide invaluable skills. Fans of Evie Dunsmore and Elizabeth Everett will enjoy this novel. Gus and Julia and great characters, and we can’t wait to read more about them in their second book, “The Ladies Road Guide to Utter Ruin,” which comes out in 2025.

Please note we receive a commission from purchases you make, which helps keep our site running – thank you!